Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey, co-founded by the renowned Conor McGregor, has taken the spirits world by storm. Its name, a nod to McGregor’s hometown of Crumlin, Dublin 12, has instantly recognizable branding. However, beyond the celebrity endorsement, lies a crucial question for whiskey enthusiasts: is Proper No. Twelve truly enjoyable, particularly when served on the rocks? This detailed exploration will delve into the whiskey’s profile, how it fares with ice, and what alternatives might offer a more rewarding experience.
Understanding Proper No. Twelve: A Profile
Before evaluating its suitability for enjoying on the rocks, it’s essential to understand the whiskey’s core characteristics. Proper No. Twelve is a blended Irish whiskey, meaning it’s a combination of grain and single malt whiskeys sourced from various distilleries in Ireland.
This blending approach is common in Irish whiskey production and allows for a consistent flavor profile to be achieved. The whiskey undergoes triple distillation, a hallmark of Irish whiskey production, contributing to its smoothness.
The maturation process primarily takes place in ex-bourbon barrels. This imbues the whiskey with characteristic notes of vanilla, honey, and toasted oak. These are all expected traits from bourbon barrel aging.
Proper No. Twelve is typically bottled at 40% ABV (alcohol by volume), which is the standard for many Irish whiskeys.
The flavor profile is generally described as approachable and relatively mild. Expect sweet notes of honey, vanilla, and a subtle fruitiness, complemented by a light spiciness. The finish tends to be short to medium in length, with a lingering sweetness and gentle warmth.
The Impact of Ice: Dilution and Temperature
Serving any whiskey on the rocks fundamentally alters its composition. The addition of ice introduces two key factors: dilution and temperature change.
Dilution is inevitable. As the ice melts, it introduces water into the whiskey. The extent of dilution depends on the amount of ice used, the temperature of the whiskey and the ice, and the ambient temperature. Dilution can mellow the whiskey’s intensity, potentially softening harsh edges and making it more approachable, but it can also mute delicate flavors.
Lowering the temperature affects the viscosity of the whiskey, making it feel thinner in the mouth. Chilling can also suppress the volatile compounds responsible for aroma and flavor. Some flavors become muted, while others may become more pronounced. Often, chilling a whiskey can mask imperfections, but it can also dull the overall experience.
Proper No. Twelve on the Rocks: Pros and Cons
Considering the whiskey’s profile and the effects of ice, let’s analyze the pros and cons of enjoying Proper No. Twelve on the rocks:
Potential Benefits
- Mellowing the Intensity: Proper No. Twelve, while generally smooth, can have a slight alcohol bite, particularly for those new to whiskey. Ice can soften this bite, making it more palatable.
- Enhancing Sweetness: Chilling can sometimes accentuate the sweeter notes of vanilla and honey, making the whiskey seem more dessert-like. This might appeal to those who prefer sweeter drinks.
- Refreshing: On a warm day, the chilled aspect of Proper No. Twelve on the rocks can be quite refreshing. This makes it a more suitable option for casual sipping in warmer climates.
- Masking Imperfections: While not necessarily a flaw, Proper No. Twelve may have a slightly young character. Chilling can minimize this, creating a smoother impression.
Potential Drawbacks
- Dilution of Flavor: The most significant drawback is the dilution of the whiskey’s inherent flavors. As the ice melts, the delicate notes of vanilla, honey, and spice can become muted, leading to a less complex and less rewarding experience.
- Loss of Complexity: Whiskey, especially when crafted with care, offers a range of subtle nuances. Chilling can suppress these nuances, resulting in a flatter and less interesting flavor profile.
- Thinning the Texture: The lower temperature can thin out the whiskey’s texture, making it feel less substantial in the mouth. This can diminish the overall sensory experience.
- Watering Down the Finish: The finish of Proper No. Twelve is already relatively short. Dilution can shorten it even further, leaving a less satisfying aftertaste.
Alternatives to Ice: Exploring Other Options
If you’re hesitant about serving Proper No. Twelve on the rocks, several alternatives can enhance your enjoyment without sacrificing flavor.
Neat
Serving the whiskey neat (without any additions) allows you to fully appreciate its inherent flavor profile. Pour a small amount into a glass and swirl it gently to release the aromas. Take small sips to savor the flavors and experience the finish.
With a Splash of Water
Adding a small splash of water can open up the whiskey’s flavors and aromas. The water breaks the surface tension, allowing more volatile compounds to evaporate, enhancing the overall sensory experience.
Whiskey Stones
Whiskey stones are non-porous stones that can be chilled and added to whiskey to cool it down without diluting it. This allows you to enjoy a chilled whiskey without sacrificing flavor.
Cocktails
Proper No. Twelve can be a versatile ingredient in cocktails. Its smooth profile and approachable flavor make it well-suited for classic Irish whiskey cocktails like the Irish Coffee, the Old Fashioned (using Irish whiskey), or a simple whiskey ginger.
Proper No. Twelve Cocktails: Recipes to Consider
While enjoying Proper No. Twelve neat or with a splash of water allows for a purist experience, its versatility shines in cocktails. Here are a couple of recipes to consider:
Proper Irish Coffee
- 1.5 oz Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey
- 4 oz Hot Coffee
- 1 oz Irish Cream Liqueur (e.g., Bailey’s)
- Whipped Cream
Instructions:
- Warm a glass mug.
- Add the whiskey and hot coffee.
- Stir in the Irish Cream liqueur.
- Top with whipped cream.
Proper Old Fashioned
- 2 oz Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey
- 1 Sugar Cube (or 1 tsp simple syrup)
- 2 Dashes Angostura Bitters
- Orange Peel
Instructions:
- Muddle the sugar cube with bitters in an old-fashioned glass.
- Add the whiskey and ice.
- Stir well until chilled.
- Garnish with an orange peel.
These recipes highlight the whiskey’s ability to complement other ingredients without being overpowered.
Tasting Notes and Expert Opinions
While personal preference reigns supreme, considering professional reviews and tasting notes can offer valuable insights. Many whiskey critics describe Proper No. Twelve as a decent, entry-level Irish whiskey. Common descriptors include:
- Aroma: Vanilla, honey, slight cereal notes, a touch of green apple.
- Palate: Sweet, smooth, vanilla, caramel, a hint of spice (cinnamon or ginger), slightly thin mouthfeel.
- Finish: Short to medium, sweet, with a gentle warmth.
Critics generally agree that it’s an approachable and easy-drinking whiskey, but it lacks the complexity and depth of some other Irish whiskeys in its price range. Some reviewers suggest that it’s best suited for mixing in cocktails or for those new to whiskey.
Price Point and Value Proposition
Proper No. Twelve is typically positioned as a mid-range Irish whiskey. Its price point often makes it an attractive option for those seeking an accessible and affordable Irish whiskey.
However, when considering value, it’s essential to compare it to other Irish whiskeys in a similar price range. Some alternatives might offer a more complex and rewarding experience for the same price.
Who Is Proper No. Twelve Best Suited For?
Considering its flavor profile and characteristics, Proper No. Twelve is arguably best suited for:
- Beginners: Its smooth, approachable flavor and lack of harshness make it an excellent entry point for those new to whiskey.
- Cocktail Enthusiasts: Its versatility allows it to be used in a wide range of cocktails, adding a smooth Irish whiskey base to various recipes.
- Those Seeking an Affordable and Accessible Irish Whiskey: Its price point makes it an attractive option for those looking for a decent Irish whiskey without breaking the bank.
The Verdict: Proper No. Twelve on the Rocks
Ultimately, whether or not Proper No. Twelve is “good” on the rocks is subjective and depends on individual preferences.
If you prefer a mellow, chilled drink and don’t mind sacrificing some complexity, then Proper No. Twelve on the rocks might be enjoyable.
However, if you want to fully appreciate the whiskey’s flavors and aromas, consider serving it neat, with a splash of water, or using whiskey stones. Explore different options and determine what best suits your palate.
Alternatives to Proper No. Twelve: Exploring Other Irish Whiskeys
For those seeking alternatives to Proper No. Twelve, particularly for enjoying neat or on the rocks (or avoiding the rocks altogether), several other Irish whiskeys offer compelling options:
- Jameson: A classic Irish whiskey known for its smoothness and versatility. It’s a slightly more complex choice than Proper Twelve.
- Tullamore D.E.W.: A blended Irish whiskey with a slightly spicier character than Proper Twelve.
- Bushmills Original: Another popular blended Irish whiskey with a smooth and approachable flavor profile.
- Teeling Small Batch: A more premium option offering a richer and more complex flavor profile.
- Redbreast 12 Year Old: A single pot still Irish whiskey, known for its rich and fruity character. It has a superior taste profile.
These alternatives provide a range of flavor profiles and price points, allowing you to find an Irish whiskey that perfectly suits your taste. Ultimately, the best way to determine which whiskey you prefer is to sample a variety and discover your personal favorites. The world of Irish whiskey is vast and filled with exciting discoveries waiting to be made.
FAQ 1: What are the general flavor characteristics of Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey?
Proper No. Twelve is typically described as having a smooth, approachable flavor profile. You can expect notes of vanilla, honey, and toasted oak, stemming from its aging in ex-bourbon barrels. It also often exhibits a slight spice, making it generally easy to drink, even for those new to whiskey.
Compared to some more complex Irish whiskeys, Proper No. Twelve leans towards a simpler, sweeter taste. This characteristic makes it a popular choice for mixed drinks, as it blends well without overpowering other ingredients. However, this also means that some whiskey aficionados might find it lacking in depth when compared to higher-end Irish whiskeys.
FAQ 2: Does adding ice enhance or diminish the flavors of Proper No. Twelve?
Adding ice to Proper No. Twelve can be a double-edged sword. The initial effect is to chill the whiskey, which can slightly mute some of the more subtle aromas. This can be a benefit if you find the whiskey a bit harsh on its own, as the coldness can smooth it out.
As the ice melts, the whiskey is diluted, which can further soften the flavor profile. Some find this dilution undesirable, as it can wash away the nuances of the whiskey. However, others appreciate the lighter, less intense experience, especially in warmer weather.
FAQ 3: How does Proper No. Twelve on the rocks compare to drinking it neat?
Drinking Proper No. Twelve neat allows you to experience the full spectrum of flavors, from the initial sweetness to the subtle spicy finish. You can appreciate the aroma and the mouthfeel without any interference. It also gives you a better understanding of the whiskey’s true character.
On the rocks, the chill and slight dilution can mask some of the complexities found when drinking it neat. The sweetness might become more pronounced as the initial bite is softened. Ultimately, it depends on your personal preference. If you prefer a more intense experience, neat is the way to go, while on the rocks is a more mellow option.
FAQ 4: What are the ideal types of ice to use with Proper No. Twelve?
Larger ice cubes or spheres are generally preferred when drinking whiskey on the rocks, including Proper No. Twelve. The larger surface area of the ice melts slower, meaning the whiskey is diluted at a more gradual pace. This allows you to enjoy the drink for a longer period without it becoming overly watery.
Smaller ice cubes melt much faster, leading to quicker dilution. While this can be beneficial if you want to rapidly chill the whiskey, it can also result in a watered-down drink in a short amount of time. Avoid using crushed ice for Proper No. Twelve on the rocks for this reason.
FAQ 5: Are there specific occasions or settings where Proper No. Twelve on the rocks is most suitable?
Proper No. Twelve on the rocks is often a good choice for casual gatherings or social events. The relaxed nature of the drink makes it approachable and easy to enjoy without demanding too much attention. It’s well-suited for warmer weather when a chilled beverage is more appealing.
In situations where you want to savor the nuances of a higher-end whiskey, Proper No. Twelve on the rocks might not be the ideal choice. However, when the goal is simply to have a refreshing and easy-drinking spirit, it can be a perfectly acceptable and enjoyable option.
FAQ 6: Can adding a splash of water to Proper No. Twelve achieve a similar effect as ice?
Adding a splash of water to Proper No. Twelve can indeed unlock some of the hidden aromas and flavors. The water breaks the surface tension, allowing volatile compounds to release, enhancing the overall sensory experience. This is a technique often used by experienced whiskey drinkers to better appreciate the spirit.
While it achieves a similar goal of softening the flavor and potentially releasing more aromas, it differs from ice in that it doesn’t chill the whiskey. The dilution is also more controlled with water, allowing you to experiment with the amount and find the perfect balance for your palate.
FAQ 7: What are some alternative ways to enjoy Proper No. Twelve besides neat or on the rocks?
Proper No. Twelve is very versatile and lends itself well to a variety of cocktails. It’s a great base for classic Irish cocktails like an Irish Coffee or an Irish Mule. Its smooth profile also makes it a good substitute in any whiskey-based cocktail that calls for a more approachable flavor.
Beyond cocktails, Proper No. Twelve can also be enjoyed with simple mixers like ginger ale or cola. These combinations highlight the whiskey’s sweetness and spice notes, making for a refreshing and easy-to-drink beverage. The possibilities are extensive, allowing you to find a way to enjoy it that suits your personal preferences.