Achieving the perfect slicked-back hairstyle requires the right product. The two titans in the hair styling arena for this iconic look are gel and pomade. Both offer distinct advantages and disadvantages, making the choice dependent on your hair type, desired hold, preferred finish, and overall lifestyle. Understanding these nuances is crucial to avoid a greasy mess or a style that wilts under pressure.
Understanding the Fundamentals: Gel
Gel has been a staple in men’s grooming for decades. It’s known for its ability to deliver a strong, almost unyielding hold. This is largely due to its water-based composition, which allows it to dry quickly and create a stiff, sculpted look. The strength of the hold can range from light to extreme, catering to various hair thicknesses and lengths.
The Pros of Using Gel for Slicked-Back Hair
Extreme Hold: This is arguably gel’s biggest selling point. If you need your hair to stay perfectly in place all day, regardless of the weather or activity, gel is a reliable option. It can withstand wind, humidity, and even some physical exertion.
Defined Texture: Gel excels at creating defined texture, particularly in shorter hair. It can emphasize individual strands, giving the hair a more structured and deliberate appearance.
High Shine (Usually): Many gels, especially traditional formulas, offer a high-shine finish. This can contribute to a polished, sophisticated look that is synonymous with classic slicked-back styles.
Water-Based Formula: The water-based nature of gel makes it relatively easy to wash out. Unlike some oil-based pomades, gel typically rinses clean with just shampoo and water, minimizing product buildup.
Affordability: Gel is generally more affordable than pomade, making it an accessible option for those on a budget.
The Cons of Using Gel for Slicked-Back Hair
Stiffness and Crunchiness: The strong hold of gel often comes at the expense of flexibility. Hair can become stiff and crunchy, which may not be desirable for those who prefer a more natural feel. Overuse can lead to flaking and a brittle texture.
Potential for Damage: Some gels, especially those with high alcohol content, can be drying to the hair. Prolonged use can lead to damage, breakage, and even scalp irritation.
Lack of Flexibility: Once gel sets, it’s difficult to restyle the hair without adding more product. This can be inconvenient for those who like to adjust their hairstyle throughout the day.
Not Ideal for All Hair Types: Gel can be too heavy for fine hair, weighing it down and making it look limp. It may also not provide enough hold for very thick or coarse hair, unless a very strong hold gel is used.
Decoding the Details: Pomade
Pomade, with its rich history rooted in classic barbering, provides a different approach to styling. It’s known for its flexibility, shine, and ability to create a smooth, polished look without the stiffness associated with gel. Pomades come in various forms, including oil-based, water-based, and wax-based, each offering unique properties.
The Pros of Using Pomade for Slicked-Back Hair
Flexibility and Restylability: This is pomade’s defining characteristic. It allows you to reshape and adjust your hairstyle throughout the day without needing to add more product. This is a significant advantage for those who value versatility.
Natural Shine: Pomades typically provide a natural, healthy-looking shine that is less artificial than some gels. This creates a more subtle and refined finish.
Nourishing Properties (Oil-Based): Oil-based pomades can help to moisturize and nourish the hair, promoting healthy growth and preventing dryness. They can also add a significant amount of shine and manageability.
Variety of Hold Strengths: Pomades are available in a range of hold strengths, from light to heavy, allowing you to customize the level of control you need.
Suitable for Various Hair Types: Pomade can work well for a wide range of hair types, from fine to thick, depending on the formulation and hold strength.
The Cons of Using Pomade for Slicked-Back Hair
Potential for Greasiness: Oil-based pomades, in particular, can be greasy and difficult to wash out. This can lead to product buildup and a heavy, weighed-down feeling.
Can Stain Clothing: Oil-based pomades can transfer to clothing and pillows, potentially leaving stains.
Hold May Not Be as Strong as Gel: While heavy-hold pomades are available, they generally don’t provide the same level of unyielding hold as strong-hold gels.
Water-Based Can Flake: While easier to wash out than oil-based, some water-based pomades can flake if overused or if they dry out too much.
Higher Price Point: Pomade is often more expensive than gel, particularly high-quality, salon-grade formulations.
Water-Based vs. Oil-Based Pomades: A Closer Look
The pomade category itself is further divided into water-based and oil-based varieties. Understanding the differences between these two types is crucial for making the right choice.
Water-Based Pomades
Water-based pomades offer the best of both worlds – the flexibility and shine of pomade with the ease of washing out associated with gel. They provide a strong hold, but with more pliability than gel, and they rinse clean with water and shampoo.
Advantages of Water-Based Pomades:
Easy to Wash Out: The primary advantage is their water-soluble nature, making them easy to remove without the need for harsh shampoos.
Less Greasy: They tend to be less greasy than oil-based pomades, reducing the risk of product buildup and a weighed-down feeling.
Variety of Holds and Finishes: Water-based pomades are available in a wide range of holds and finishes, catering to various hair types and styling preferences.
Disadvantages of Water-Based Pomades:
Can Dry Out: Some water-based pomades can dry out over time, leading to a slightly stiff or crunchy texture, though usually less so than gel.
May Flake: Overuse or using the wrong type of water-based pomade can cause flaking.
Hold Not Always as Strong as Oil-Based: While offering decent hold, they may not always match the extreme hold capabilities of some oil-based pomades, especially in very thick or coarse hair.
Oil-Based Pomades
Oil-based pomades are the classic choice, known for their superior hold, shine, and ability to keep hair in place all day. They are particularly effective for achieving a smooth, polished look and are often preferred by those with thicker or coarser hair.
Advantages of Oil-Based Pomades:
Strong Hold: Oil-based pomades typically offer a very strong hold, making them ideal for demanding hairstyles like slicked-backs.
High Shine: They provide a classic, glossy shine that is characteristic of vintage hairstyles.
Moisturizing Properties: The oils in these pomades can help to moisturize and condition the hair, preventing dryness and breakage.
Disadvantages of Oil-Based Pomades:
Difficult to Wash Out: The main drawback of oil-based pomades is their difficulty to remove. They often require multiple washes with strong shampoos and can leave a residue even after washing.
Greasy Texture: They can be quite greasy, leading to product buildup and a weighed-down feeling, especially if used excessively.
Can Stain: Oil-based pomades can transfer to clothing, pillows, and other surfaces, leaving stains.
Choosing the Right Product for Your Hair Type
The best product for your slicked-back hairstyle depends heavily on your hair type. Here’s a general guide:
Fine Hair: Water-based pomades with a light to medium hold are generally best for fine hair. They provide enough control without weighing the hair down. Avoid heavy gels and oil-based pomades, which can make fine hair look limp and greasy. A lightweight gel, used sparingly, can also work.
Medium Hair: Both gel and pomade can work well for medium hair, depending on the desired look and hold. For a strong, sculpted look with high shine, gel is a good option. For a more flexible, natural look with a healthy shine, a water-based or oil-based pomade (depending on preference and washability) is a better choice.
Thick or Coarse Hair: Thick or coarse hair requires a product with a strong hold. Strong-hold gels or oil-based pomades are typically the best options. Oil-based pomades can provide the necessary control and shine while also helping to moisturize and tame unruly hair. Water-based pomades with a heavy hold can also work, but may require more product.
Dry Hair: Individuals with dry hair should lean towards oil-based pomades, as they offer moisturizing benefits. Be cautious of gels with high alcohol content, which can exacerbate dryness. If using gel, consider a hydrating gel or use a leave-in conditioner beforehand.
Oily Hair: Those with oily hair should opt for water-based pomades or gels with a lighter hold. Avoid oil-based pomades, which can make oily hair look even greasier. Regular shampooing is essential to prevent product buildup.
Application Techniques for Gel and Pomade
Regardless of the product you choose, proper application is crucial for achieving the perfect slicked-back hairstyle.
Applying Gel:
-
Start with damp hair: Gel works best when applied to damp hair, as this allows for even distribution and better hold.
-
Use a small amount: Start with a small amount of gel (about a dime-sized amount) and add more as needed. Overusing gel can lead to a stiff, crunchy, and flaky finish.
-
Work the gel through the hair: Rub the gel between your palms and then work it through the hair from roots to ends, ensuring even coverage.
-
Style the hair: Use a comb to style the hair into a slicked-back style, creating a clean and defined look.
-
Allow to dry: Allow the gel to dry completely for maximum hold. Avoid touching the hair while it’s drying, as this can disrupt the style.
Applying Pomade:
-
Start with dry or slightly damp hair: Pomade can be applied to either dry or slightly damp hair, depending on the desired level of hold and shine. Dry hair will result in a stronger hold and more matte finish, while slightly damp hair will provide more shine.
-
Emulsify the pomade: Scoop a small amount of pomade (about a dime-sized amount) and rub it between your palms to emulsify it. This will make it easier to apply evenly.
-
Work the pomade through the hair: Work the pomade through the hair from roots to ends, ensuring even coverage.
-
Style the hair: Use a comb to style the hair into a slicked-back style, creating a smooth and polished look.
-
Restyle as needed: One of the benefits of pomade is its restylability. You can use your fingers or a comb to reshape the hair throughout the day as needed.
The Verdict: Finding What Works for You
Ultimately, the choice between gel and pomade for a slicked-back hairstyle is a matter of personal preference. Consider your hair type, desired hold, preferred finish, and lifestyle when making your decision. Experiment with different products and application techniques to find what works best for you. Don’t be afraid to try different brands and formulations until you achieve the perfect slicked-back look. Remember that achieving the ideal hairstyle often involves a bit of trial and error.
What are the main differences between gel and pomade when styling a slicked-back hairstyle?
Gel typically provides a very firm hold and a wet or shiny finish, often resulting in a sculpted and rigid look. It’s best suited for hairstyles that need to stay in place all day without any movement. The ingredients often include alcohol, which can lead to dryness if used excessively.
Pomade, on the other hand, offers more flexibility and a variety of finishes, ranging from matte to high shine. It allows for restyling throughout the day and generally doesn’t dry out the hair as much as gel. Pomades are available in water-based and oil-based formulas, each offering different levels of hold and shine.
Which hair type is better suited for gel when creating a slicked-back look?
Gel is generally better suited for those with fine or thin hair that struggles to hold its shape. The strong hold of gel can provide the necessary structure and volume to create a noticeable slicked-back style. It can also be effective for shorter hair lengths where a controlled and defined look is desired.
However, individuals with thick or coarse hair may find that gel doesn’t provide enough pliability and can result in a stiff and unnatural appearance. For these hair types, a product with more moisture and flexibility, such as a pomade, might be a more suitable choice.
Which hair type is better suited for pomade when creating a slicked-back look?
Pomade is often the preferred choice for those with medium to thick hair, as it provides sufficient hold without making the hair feel stiff or crunchy. Its ability to maintain moisture also makes it a good option for dry or coarse hair that needs hydration and manageability to achieve a sleek look.
Furthermore, pomade’s versatility allows for different levels of shine, making it suitable for achieving both classic and modern slicked-back hairstyles. Individuals with wavy or curly hair can also benefit from pomade’s ability to control frizz and define their natural texture while still maintaining a polished appearance.
How do you apply gel correctly for a slicked-back hairstyle to avoid flaking?
To avoid flaking when using gel for a slicked-back hairstyle, it’s crucial to apply the product evenly to damp hair. Start with a small amount, rub it between your palms to warm it up, and then work it through your hair from roots to ends, ensuring every strand is coated. This prevents product buildup in certain areas.
Avoid using excessive amounts of gel, as this is the most common cause of flaking. Once the gel is applied, use a fine-tooth comb to style your hair back and create the desired shape. If you need more hold, add another very small amount of gel, focusing on the areas that require extra control.
How do you apply pomade correctly for a slicked-back hairstyle to achieve the desired hold and shine?
The key to applying pomade correctly is to start with a small amount and gradually build up the desired hold and shine. Warm the pomade between your hands to emulsify it and make it easier to distribute evenly throughout your hair. Begin applying at the back of your head, working your way forward, to ensure the style is secure.
For a stronger hold, apply pomade to slightly damp hair. For more shine, apply it to dry hair. Use a comb to style the hair back, creating a clean and defined line. Add more pomade as needed to achieve the desired level of hold and shine, paying attention to areas that require extra attention.
Can you mix gel and pomade for a slicked-back hairstyle? What are the potential benefits and drawbacks?
Mixing gel and pomade can be a viable option to achieve a customized slicked-back style, combining the strengths of both products. The gel can provide the initial strong hold and structure, while the pomade adds flexibility, shine, and control. This combination can be especially useful for individuals with hair that is difficult to manage.
However, there are potential drawbacks to consider. Mixing incompatible products can lead to flaking, a greasy appearance, or an inconsistent hold. It’s important to experiment with small amounts of different gel and pomade combinations to find the right balance for your hair type and desired style. Start with less product than you think you need.
How do you remove gel and pomade from your hair without causing damage or buildup?
Removing gel effectively requires a thorough rinsing with warm water to loosen the product. Follow up with a clarifying shampoo to remove any remaining residue. Massaging the scalp gently during shampooing will help to dislodge any product that may be clinging to the hair follicles. Condition afterward to replenish moisture.
Removing pomade, especially oil-based pomade, may require a different approach. Start by applying a generous amount of conditioner to dry hair and letting it sit for a few minutes. Then, rinse with warm water and follow with a clarifying shampoo. You may need to shampoo twice to fully remove the pomade. A final conditioning treatment is essential to prevent dryness and maintain healthy hair.